The Pros and Cons of Asphalt Shingle Roofing Explained | Big Easy Roofing FREE Roofing Estimates
24 Hour Roof Replacement Guarantee
Call Icon Top

Call Our Roofing Experts! (504) 800-8196

man putting shingle roofing on commercial roof

The Pros and Cons of Asphalt Shingle Roofing Explained

Weighing the pros and cons of asphalt shingle roofing is critical, taking into account aspects such as longevity, affordability, appearance, and upkeep needs. As one of the most popular roofing materials on the market today, asphalt shingles have a lot to offer homeowners and business owners alike.

In this comprehensive blog post about the pros and cons of asphalt roofing, we will delve into their advantages such as their impressive durability in various weather conditions, cost-effective nature compared to other types of roofing materials like metal or wood shingles, and an extensive array of styles and colors that can enhance your property’s curb appeal.

However, no material is perfect. We will also explore some disadvantages associated with asphalt shingle roofs.

To ensure you make an informed decision regarding your roof replacement project or new construction endeavor involving an asphalt roof installation process – we’ll discuss maintenance tips for keeping your investment in top condition over time by performing regular inspections/cleanings while addressing any necessary repairs/replacements promptly.

Lastly, we’ll provide guidance on selecting the right contractor who specializes in installing these types of roofs.

Table of Contents:

Advantages of Asphalt Shingle Roofing

Asphalt shingle roofing is a popular choice among homeowners and business owners alike due to its numerous benefits. In this section, we will discuss the durability, cost-effectiveness, and variety of styles and colors that asphalt shingle roofing offers.

a. Durability

One of the main advantages of asphalt roofing is its durability. These roofs are designed to withstand various weather conditions such as rain, snow, and even moderate hailstorms without significant damage. Additionally, they have a Class A fire rating which means they offer excellent protection against fires.

b. Cost-Effective

Another advantage of asphalt shingle roofing is its cost-effectiveness compared to other types of materials like metal or slate roofs. The initial installation costs for an asphalt roof are typically lower than those for alternative materials while still providing long-lasting protection for your home or business establishment.

  • Affordable material: Asphalt shingles are generally less expensive than other options on the market.
  • Ease of installation: Due to their lightweight nature and simple design, installing an asphalt roof can be quicker and more affordable than with other materials.
  • Limited maintenance: With proper care (discussed later in this article), you can expect minimal upkeep expenses throughout the lifespan of your asphalt roof.

c. Variety of Styles and Colors

different asphalt shingle roofs

Property owners looking to boost the visual appeal of their building without going over budget often find asphalt roofs an appealing choice due to their versatility.

For those wanting to customize their roof’s appearance to match the architectural style of their home or business, asphalt shingles provide a wide range of styles and colors. Some popular options include:

  • 3-tab shingles: These traditional, flat-looking shingles are an economical choice for those seeking a simple yet functional roofing solution.
  • Architectural/dimensional shingles: Featuring multiple layers and unique shapes, these premium asphalt shingles offer enhanced durability and aesthetic appeal compared to their 3-tab counterparts.
  • Luxury/designer shingles: For property owners who desire a high-end look without opting for more expensive materials like slate or wood shakes, luxury asphalt shingle options can provide the desired effect at a fraction of the cost.

In summary, choosing asphalt shingle roofing offers numerous advantages such as durability against various weather conditions, cost-effectiveness when compared with other types of roofs, and an extensive variety of styles and colors that cater to different preferences. This makes it an ideal option for both residential homes and commercial establishments alike.

Overall, asphalt shingle roofing offers many advantages such as durability, cost-effectiveness and a variety of styles and colors. Yet, before settling on asphalt shingle roofing as the ideal material for your dwelling or enterprise, there are some potential drawbacks to take into account.

Disadvantages of Asphalt Shingle Roofing

Before making a decision, it is important to consider the potential drawbacks of asphalt shingle roofing, which may include susceptibility to hail and wind damage, shorter lifespan compared to other materials, and risk of leaks or moisture damage. In this section, we will discuss some disadvantages associated with asphalt shingle roofs, including susceptibility to damage from hail and wind, shorter lifespan compared to other materials, and potential for leaks and moisture damage.

a. Susceptible to Damage from Hail and Wind

Asphalt shingles are not as resistant to extreme weather conditions as some other roofing materials like metal or tile. Hail and wind can cause these shingles to shatter or come off, leading to water entering your building if not taken care of. This could lead to water infiltration into your home or business establishment if left unaddressed.

b. Short Lifespan Compared to Other Materials

The average lifespan of an asphalt shingle roof ranges between 15-30 years depending on factors such as installation quality, maintenance practices, climate conditions in your area, etc. whereas alternative options like metal roofing can last up to 50 years or more with proper care. If you’re looking for a long-lasting solution without frequent replacements needed over time then asphalt might not be the best option available.

  • Metal Roofs: Can last up to 50+ years with proper maintenance.
  • Slate Roofs: Known for their durability, slate roofs can last over 100 years.
  • Tile Roofs: Clay and concrete tile roofs have a lifespan of 50+ years when maintained correctly.

c. Potential for Leaks and Moisture Damage

Asphalt shingle roofing is more prone to leaks than some other materials due to its composition and design. The overlapping pattern of the shingles can allow water to seep through if not properly sealed or installed, leading to moisture damage within your home or business establishment.

Additionally, poor ventilation in attic spaces may cause condensation buildup on the underside of asphalt shingles which could lead to mold growth. Regular inspections are necessary for identifying any potential issues early on before they escalate into costly repairs down the line.

Despite the drawbacks of asphalt shingle roofing, it can still be a cost-effective and reliable choice when properly maintained. Regular upkeep is key to preserving the integrity of your asphalt shingle roof and making sure it lasts for a long time.

Maintenance Requirements for Asphalt Shingle Roofs

Maintaining your asphalt shingle roof is essential to ensure its longevity and performance. By following a few simple maintenance steps, you can prevent potential issues such as leaks, moisture damage, and premature wear on your roofing system. In this section, we will discuss the importance of regular inspections and cleanings, repairing or replacing damaged shingles, and sealing around vents, pipes, and chimneys.

a. Regular Inspections and Cleanings

Conducting regular inspections of your asphalt shingle roof is crucial in identifying any signs of damage or wear before they become major problems. Twice annually, it’s wise to examine your asphalt shingle roof – once following the winter months and then again prior to harsher weather conditions.

Roof cleaning is also an important aspect of maintaining an asphalt shingle roof. Removing debris such as leaves, branches, and dirt buildup from valleys between slopes helps maintain proper water drainage off the roof surface preventing possible leaks or other damages caused by standing water.

b. Repairing or Replacing Damaged Shingles

If during inspection you find damaged or missing shingles it’s vital to address these issues promptly to avoid further complications like leaks leading to interior damages within your home/business structure which could result in costly repairs down the line not just limited exterior but potentially inside well too.

Damage shingle roof- Big Easy Roofing

  • Repair: Minor damages like small cracks can be repaired using roofing cement applied with a putty knife under the cracked area then pressing firmly back into place ensuring a good seal is formed stopping any future leaking possibilities due to cracks being present previously.
  • Replace: For more severe damages like larger cracks, curled edges or missing shingles altogether it’s best practice to replace the affected area entirely new piece matching the original style/color ensuring a seamless appearance overall.

c. Sealing Around Vents, Pipes, and Chimneys

Sealing around roof penetrations such as vents, pipes, and chimneys is crucial in preventing water infiltration into your home or business structure. Over time sealants can deteriorate due to weather exposure causing gaps and allowing moisture to enter potentially leading to costly repairs if not addressed promptly.

To maintain proper sealing make sure to inspect these areas during routine inspections looking for signs of wear and tear then reapplying the appropriate sealant material needed to ensure a tight waterproof barrier is formed stopping any possible leaks from occurring future protecting investment in the long run.

In addition hiring a professional roofing contractor like Big Easy Roofing, which specializes in asphalt shingle installations/repairs will provide peace of mind knowing the job is done right leaving you enjoying the benefits of beautiful, durable and cost-effective options for many years to come.

Maintaining an asphalt shingle roof requires regular inspections and cleanings, repairs or replacements of damaged shingles, and sealing around vents, pipes, and chimneys. With the right contractor on your side to install a new roof or repair existing damage properly from the start is essential for any homeowner considering this type of roofing material.

Choosing the Right Contractor for Asphalt Shingle Roof Installation

When it comes to installing an asphalt shingle roof, selecting the right contractor is crucial to ensure a successful and long-lasting project. In this section, we will provide guidance on researching local companies and reviews, verifying licenses, insurance, and bonding, as well as requesting estimates and references when choosing a roofing contractor.

a. Researching Local Companies and Reviews

The first step in finding the right contractor for your asphalt shingle roof installation is conducting thorough research on local companies. Start by asking friends or neighbors for recommendations of reputable contractors they have worked with in the past. Additionally, utilize online resources such as Better Business Bureau (BBB), Yelp, or Google Maps to read customer reviews and ratings of potential contractors in your area.

b. Verifying Licenses, Insurance, and Bonding

Prioritize working with licensed professionals who carry adequate insurance coverage to protect both you and their employees during the project’s duration. Verify that prospective contractors hold valid licenses through your state’s licensing board website or ask them directly for proof of licensure before hiring them.

  • Licensing: Ensure that the roofing company has all necessary permits required by your city or county regulations.
  • Insurance: Confirm that they carry general liability insurance covering property damage caused during work execution along with workers’ compensation policies protecting their team members from workplace injuries.
  • Bonding: Bonding protects you as a homeowner in case the contractor fails to complete the project or meet contractual obligations. Make sure your chosen roofing company is bonded.

c. Requesting Estimates and References

Once you have narrowed down your list of potential contractors, request detailed written estimates from each one outlining labor costs, materials used, and projected timelines for completion. Once you’ve narrowed down your list of possible contractors, comparing their offerings and picking the one that best fits your needs and budget can be aided by obtaining detailed written estimates from each.

In addition to requesting estimates, ask each prospective contractor for references from previous clients who had similar projects completed by them. Contact these references directly to inquire about their experience working with the contractor, quality of work performed, timeliness of project completion, and overall satisfaction with the results.

Taking these steps when selecting a roofing contractor for asphalt shingle roof installation will ensure that you choose a professional who can deliver high-quality workmanship while adhering to industry standards and safety guidelines throughout the entire process.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most common damage to asphalt shingles?

The most common types of damages affecting asphalt shingles are curling edges due to thermal expansion/contraction cycles; granule loss caused by weather exposure; cracks resulting from aging; punctures or tears due to impact (e.g., falling tree branches); lifting corners because of strong winds; algae growth on damp surfaces. Learn more about these damages here.

How many years should a new asphalt shingle roof last?

A new asphalt shingle roof typically lasts between 15-30 years depending on factors such as climate conditions in your area (extreme heat/cold), proper installation practices followed by contractors & regular maintenance performed by homeowners. Higher-quality architectural/dimensional/laminated versions may offer longer lifespans of up to 50 years with adequate care.


In conclusion, asphalt shingle roofing is a great option for those looking to replace their existing roofs or install new ones. While it has its drawbacks like any other type of roofing material, the advantages far outweigh them and make this an attractive choice for many homeowners.

It is essential to contemplate the benefits and drawbacks of asphalt shingle roofing prior to settling on a choice so as to make certain you are receiving the most ideal value for your cash. Additionally, selecting a reputable contractor with experience in installing asphalt shingle roofs will ensure that your installation goes smoothly and lasts for years to come.

Big Easy Roofing offers a 24-hour roof replacement guarantee. Call now for more information or get a free estimate.
Related Posts

4 Best Roofing Materials for Solar Panels

Ever found yourself staring at your roof, wondering what its true potential c...

Read More

How to Choose the Best Roofing Material for Your Home

When selecting a roofing material for your home, there are numerous factors t...

Read More

Roof Installation Tips: How to Install a Roof Like a Pro

If you're a homeowner who wishes to install a roof but doesn't want to spend ...

Read More

When Is the Best Time to Replace a Roof

Replacing a roof is an important home improvement project that requires caref...

Read More

10 Roof Repair Tips Every Homeowner Should Know

A roof should be in top shape so that it could provide your home and family t...

Read More

How to Check for Roof Leaks

Signs of a Roof Leak When it comes to maintaining the integrity of your home...

Read More
24-Hour Roof Replacement Guarantee