Comparing Metal Roofs and Shingles: Pros & Cons | Big Easy Roofing FREE Roofing Estimates
24 Hour Roof Replacement Guarantee
Call Icon Top

Call Our Roofing Experts! (504) 800-8196

types of shingle and metal roofs

Comparing Metal Roofs and Shingles: Pros & Cons to Help You Choose the Right One

Making the correct roofing material decision for your residence can be difficult, particularly with the wide range of materials available.

To ensure you make an educated choice and get the most out of your home’s roof, this article will provide a comparison between metal roofs and shingles so that you may confidently choose what works best for your needs.

Understanding the Basics of Metal Roofs

different metal roofs

Nowadays, more and more homeowners are leaning towards metal roofing due to the numerous advantages it provides.

It is highly durable, energy-efficient requires little maintenance, and is incredibly lightweight – perfect for homes with flat or low-pitched roofs! Metal roofs come in a variety of colors and styles that can add value and curb appeal to any home.

Metal roofs are an excellent long-term investment for your home, as they can last up to 50 years or more. Furthermore, their impressive fire-, wind- and hail resistance makes them the ideal choice for homes in regions prone to natural disasters. With metal roofing, you don’t need to worry about regular repair costs!

Not only is a metal roof aesthetically pleasing, but it’s also extremely energy-efficient. Metal roofs are engineered to reflect the sun’s heat away from your home— keeping you and your family cool when temperatures soar during summer months.

This not only makes for a more enjoyable living environment but can lead to considerable savings on electricity bills as well!

Understanding the Basics of Shingles

For homeowners looking to save money, shingles are the perfect roof material. They come in a wide range of materials such as asphalt, wood, and slate, making them an incredibly versatile option for any type of home.

Furthermore, they’re inexpensive which makes them one of the most sought-after roofing options on the market today.

Shingles are often a DIYer’s go-to roofing material, as they easily install. However, shingle roofs tend to be more vulnerable when compared to metal ones and may require replacement sooner than expected due to wear from the elements.

Pros and Cons of Metal Roofs

While there are numerous advantages to selecting a metal roof, it is necessary to be aware of the potential drawbacks too. Let’s review some of the pros and cons that should be taken into consideration:


  • Durable and long-lasting
  • Resistant to fire, wind, and hail
  • Energy-efficient
  • Low maintenance
  • Lightweight and suitable for flat or low-pitched roofs


  • More expensive upfront cost
  • Noisier during heavy rain or hail
  • Requires special skills to install
  • Not as widely available in certain styles and colors

Pros and Cons of Shingles

Before you make the decision to invest in shingles for your home, it’s important that you know about the benefits and drawbacks. Let’s explore some of these:

Asphalt shingle roof on commercial roof


  • Inexpensive
  • Easy to install
  • Widely available in different materials and styles
  • Easy to repair if damaged


  • Shorter lifespan compared to metal roofs
  • Prone to damage from weather and environmental factors
  • More maintenance required
  • Not as energy-efficient as metal roofs

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Metal Roofs and Shingles

There are several factors to consider when choosing between metal roofs and shingles. Here are a few of the most important ones:

  • Cost

If you’re looking for a long-term investment, metal roofs are the way to go. Even though they may cost more upfront, they last longer and require less maintenance than shingles do.

On the other hand, shingles offer an affordable solution in terms of initial costs but may not be as durable or reliable over time due to frequent replacement needs and higher maintenance demands.

  • Durability

Unlike metal roofs, shingles are simpler to repair if harmed; however, that’s about the only advantage they have. Metal roofs offer superior fortitude and protection from fire, wind, and hail – all with much less upkeep over time.

  • Energy efficiency

Metal roofs reflect heat from the sun, making them more energy-efficient than shingles.

  • Installation

Metal roofs require special skills and knowledge to install, while shingles are relatively easy to install.

  • Weight

With metal roofing, flat or low-sloping roofs become an effortless project due to its lightweight composition. On the other hand, installing heavy shingles can be a tiring task that requires diligent labor and time.

  • Style/Colors

Metal roofs may not as widely available in certain styles and colors. Shingles are widely available in different materials and styles.


Q: How long does metal roofing typically last?

A: With proper maintenance and installation, metal roofing can last up to 50 years or more.

Q: Does metal roofing require more maintenance than shingle roofing?

A: Generally, metal roofing requires less maintenance than shingle roofing. However, metal roofs may need to be inspected periodically for signs of damage or wear and tear.

Q: Which type of material is more energy-efficient?

A: Metal roofs are generally more energy-efficient than shingle roofs as they reflect heat from the sun.


When deciding between metal roofing and shingle roofing, there are a number of pros and cons to consider. Metal roofing offers a longer lifespan, energy efficiency, and recyclability, but is typically more expensive upfront compared to shingle roofing.

On the other hand, shingle roofing is more affordable, offers a variety of options, and is easy to install, but is less durable and requires more maintenance compared to metal roofing.

In the end, selecting between metal roofs and shingles comes down to your specific requirements for your residence as well as your personal preference. Be sure to thoroughly study both options before you come up with an answer.

If in doubt, consult with a trained roofer who can provide direction on which material is suitable for your home.

For metal or shingle roofing installation, contact Big Easy Roofing. Our team offers quality service, excellent customer support, and cost-effective solutions! Give us a call today for more information or get a free estimate.

Related Posts

How to Choose the Right Siding Installation Contractor: Tips

When it comes to selecting the right siding installation contractor, making a...

Read More

The Easiest Roof to Install: A Guide to DIY Roofing Projects

Are you considering taking on a DIY roofing project? Whether you're looking t...

Read More

Do Roof Tiles Really Reduce Heat? Find Out Here!

We've all heard it: "Roof tiles reduce heat and help keep your house cooler"....

Read More

Uncover 5 Benefits of Metal Roofing You Might Not Know About

When it comes to roofing materials, these 5 metal roofing benefits are often ...

Read More

What is the Most Expensive Roof Material? Find Out Here!

Living beneath a roof is one of the basic needs of every household, but have ...

Read More
24-Hour Roof Replacement Guarantee